Abigail vs Black Hills AI / Otto IP (2026): Patent AI Comparison
Comparing two AI patent prosecution tools. Both help with Office Action responses, but with different architectures, feature depth, and pricing models.
TL;DR
AI-native platform with 10-expert tiered pipeline, Glass Box transparency, element-level prior art mapping, Prior Art Comparator, full docketing, examiner intelligence, and $49/response pricing.
AI-powered patent prosecution assistant (Otto IP) offering Office Action analysis, response drafting, and prosecution support. Focus on workflow automation and attorney-AI collaboration.
Abigail provides deeper analysis through its 10-expert pipeline and Glass Box validation, plus more comprehensive platform features (docketing, examiner intelligence, API). Black Hills AI focuses on streamlined prosecution assistance with a simpler workflow.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | Abigail | Black Hills AI |
|---|---|---|
| OA Parsing & Classification | ||
| Claim-by-Claim Analysis | ||
| Element-Level Prior Art Mapping | ||
| Prior Art Comparator (side-by-side) | ||
| 10-Expert Tiered Pipeline | ||
| Glass Box AI Transparency | ||
| New Matter Detection | ||
| 101 Eligibility Analysis | ||
| 103 Obviousness Analysis | ||
| 112 Written Description Analysis | ||
| Examiner Intelligence | ||
| Full Docket Management | ||
| USPTO PAIR Sync | ||
| 37 CFR DOCX Export | ||
| 18 Form Templates | ||
| Drawing Objection Analysis | ||
| Chemical/Sequence Support | ||
| REST API | ||
| Knowledge Library |
Pricing Comparison
Abigail
Pay-per-use: $49 per OA response export. Credit packages from $25-$2,000. No subscription. $100 free credits for new users.
Black Hills AI
Subscription-based pricing. Contact sales for current rates. Pricing varies by firm size and feature tier.
Where Each Tool Excels
Abigail Strengths
- 10-expert tiered pipeline for structured analysis
- Glass Box AI transparency with source verification
- Prior Art Comparator (unique side-by-side citation view)
- Full docketing with USPTO PAIR sync and deadline alerts
- Deep examiner intelligence (allowance rates, patterns, preferences)
- Specialty IP support (chemical, sequence, drawing analysis)
- OpenClaw REST API for developer integration
- Pay-per-use pricing accessible to solo practitioners
Black Hills AI Strengths
- Streamlined prosecution workflow
- Focus on attorney-AI collaboration model
- Growing feature set with active development
- Prosecution-specific focus (not diluted by analytics features)
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Abigail if...
You want the deepest possible analysis with Glass Box verification, need full docketing and examiner intelligence, or want pay-per-use pricing. Especially strong for complex OAs with multiple rejection types.
Choose Black Hills AI if...
You prefer a simpler prosecution assistant with a streamlined workflow and are willing to trade some analysis depth for ease of use.
Try Abigail Free
New users get $100 in free credits. Upload a real Office Action and compare the results yourself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Get Patent Prosecution Insights
Weekly tips on AI-assisted patent prosecution and tool comparisons.